CaptainMcMuffin's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[The Great Gatsby - Money]

Extra Credit?

Wow, that was nice. The music fit well with the images and the style was great. Surprisingly, it wasn't boring either. Good Job.

PauLH responds:

Glad you liked it! =)

[Doodieman: The Hero's Loa]

Good Animation, BUT(T)...

Ok, I liked the style and I liked the animation. You did a good job, but I just didn't appreciate the potty humor. All things should be used in moderation, and this was certainly a case of over use. Also, repeating just two songs over and over again for 10 minutes got annoying really fast. I might have liked it better if it was 1 minute long instead of 10.

[Ducktales 2:Residuck Evil]

Funny Stuff.

I used to have one of those LCD handheld electronic games which featured Ducktales. The Graphics of your flash reminded me of that. The jokes were funny and the style seemed to work. Good Job.

[Candy Bar]

Good Job, but could use some improvement

I thought that was fairly good. Two things that would have made it better:
1) Not having any sounds or voices, just music.
2) Having Vector instead of JPG backgrounds.

steve-matarazzo responds:

I did have one more voice sound clip in there but then I found that it felt like it didn't belong. I wanted the movie to be all music but I needed to establish that the candy bar was actually Brandon's. Vector backgrounds would be great but I have to master the art of that yet, hehe. Thanks for your review.

[Banana Fingers EP.4]

I like the sarcasm!

I'm a fan of the Salad Fingers series, and I have to say, you did a good job at creating a parody. I laughed out loud at this. Banana fingers voice is incredibly sarcastic. I think the very end was stupid, but the Seinfeld scene was funny and well cast. One complaint, the art and sound seemed to loose quality as the movie progressed. It seemed like you got a bit lazy.

[Salad Fingers Episode 4]

Even Better The Second Time

I watched this when it first came out, and I have to say that I was impressed then. I just watched it for a second time, and I picked up on so much more. You really put time into the writing and the art. Some of the tweens could be a bit better, but other than that, it's a masterpiece. It makes me want to smile and feel disgust at the same time. I especially liked the ending. Keep up the good work.

[Ordinary Conversation]

Uniquely Cool

Wow. That was surprisingly interesting. You did a superb job of putting emotion into something so plain. You brought the ordinary to life. Truly, you are a great animator.